Hårde nedlukninger af plejehjem førte til færre COVID-19-dødsfald – men flere dødsfald i alt

Det er konklusionen i et nyt working paper, Melo (2023), som også viser, at non-profit plejehjem lukkede hårdere ned end for-profit plejehjem, og havde derfor færre COVID-19-dødsfald, men altså så mange ekstra øvrige dødsfald (pga. fx forværret demens), at der samlet set døde flere på non-profit plejehjem.

Her er et forsimplet overblik over resultaterne:

Og her er abstract (min fremhævning):

This paper explores the differences in incentives and thus behavior between for-profit and not-forprofit firms. I investigate a terrible choice nursing homes faced during the pandemic: isolate residents to prevent deaths from COVID-19 but doing so may increase total deaths by aggravating mental illnesses such as dementia. I explore how ownership structure led to differences in isolation measures taken and consequently health outcomes. I model decisions regarding isolation measures as a trade-off between profits and satisfying the demands of staff, with not-for-profit managers more constrained in how they consume profits. Using cell phone location data, I find that not-for-profit facilities implemented more restrictive isolation measures during the pandemic and thus had fewer COVID-19 cases and deaths. However, not-for-profit ownership is predictive of substantially more non-COVID deaths, such that they had more total deaths than for-profit facilities.

Vito Melos bud på forskellen er forskelle i hvor stor vægt lederne af plejehjemmene tillægger interessegrupperne. Det bliver ikke udpenslet, men man kan fx forestille sig, at non-profit organisationer tager relativt mere hensyn til medarbejderne end beboerne (/kunderne).

Her er fra konklusionen:

Managerial decisions in for-profit firms will differ from managerial decisions at not-for-profit firms when preferences of interest groups within firms diverge substantially from the profit-maximizing managerial decision. In these situations, managers at not-for-profit organizations are likely to deviate more from the profit-maximizing allocation of resources than managers at for-profit firms, all else being equal. The framework in this paper can be applied to understand how ownership structures affect managerial decisions in other industries.

Skriv et svar

Dette site anvender Akismet til at reducere spam. Læs om hvordan din kommentar bliver behandlet.